Top Picks
Tiger Eye Necklace Rough Wire Wrapped Pendant
SIOBHAN’S PICK SHAMTAMTiger Eye Necklace Rough Wire Wrapped Pendant
£18.60 SHAMTAM
Yves Saint Laurent Libre Intense Eau de Parfum 50ml
ROSIE’S PICK ESCENTUALYves Saint Laurent Libre Intense Eau de Parfum 50ml
£119.00 ESCENTUAL
THOMAS SABO Connect Gold Plated Black Zirconia Heart Charm Necklace
MEGAN’S PICK JOHN GREEDTHOMAS SABO Connect Gold Plated Black Zirconia Heart Charm Necklace
£160.00 £118.50 JOHN GREED
Grandmother Heart Necklace - Thank You for Being Wonderful
MAGGIE’S PICK INSTOCKGrandmother Heart Necklace - Thank You for Being Wonderful
£15.97 INSTOCK
The Obsidian Marrow Necklace Gold
ELLIE’S PICK INSTOCKThe Obsidian Marrow Necklace Gold
£40.00 INSTOCK
How we pick

These picks came from Siobhan, Rosie, Megan, Maggie and Ellie, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

Under £5021 pieces
Nocturnal Succubus Gold Heart Pendant Necklace
INSTOCK

Nocturnal Succubus Gold Heart Pendant Necklace

£45.00 INSTOCK
Cord Necklace Gemstone Pendant
SHAMTAM

Cord Necklace Gemstone Pendant

£8.70 SHAMTAM
Nomination Bold Steel Decorative Black Zirconia Cross Necklace
JOHN GREED

Nomination Bold Steel Decorative Black Zirconia Cross Necklace

£34.00 JOHN GREED
Nomination Emosfere Steel Black Heart Bead Necklace
JOHN GREED

Nomination Emosfere Steel Black Heart Bead Necklace

£34.00 JOHN GREED
Bonmarche Double Layer Black Resin Heart Necklace
BONMARCHE

Bonmarche Double Layer Black Resin Heart Necklace

£4.50 BONMARCHE
Alchemy Gothic Witch Heart Reversible Pendant Necklace
CRONJAGER

Alchemy Gothic Witch Heart Reversible Pendant Necklace

£14.99 CRONJAGER
Essence of the Volcano Necklace
INSTOCK

Essence of the Volcano Necklace

£16.99 INSTOCK
Gunmetal Black Crystal Heart Necklace
CRONJAGER

Gunmetal Black Crystal Heart Necklace

£28.00 CRONJAGER
The Obsidian Marrow Necklace Gold
INSTOCK

The Obsidian Marrow Necklace Gold

£40.00 INSTOCK
Puff Heart Silver Necklace - 18"
INSTOCK

Puff Heart Silver Necklace - 18"

£14.97 INSTOCK
Tiger Eye Necklace Rough Wire Wrapped Pendant
SHAMTAM

Tiger Eye Necklace Rough Wire Wrapped Pendant

£18.60 SHAMTAM
Grandmother Heart Necklace - Thank You for Being Wonderful
INSTOCK

Grandmother Heart Necklace - Thank You for Being Wonderful

£15.97 INSTOCK
John Greed Signature Silver Black Onyx Heart Necklace
JOHN GREED

John Greed Signature Silver Black Onyx Heart Necklace

£36.00 JOHN GREED
Lepidolite Hexagon Pendant with Adjustable Cord
SHAMTAM

Lepidolite Hexagon Pendant with Adjustable Cord

£11.46 SHAMTAM
Bridesmaids Heart Necklace & Thank You Gift Card - 16"
INSTOCK

Bridesmaids Heart Necklace & Thank You Gift Card - 16"

£15.97 INSTOCK
Moss Agate Hexagon Pendant Necklace
SHAMTAM

Moss Agate Hexagon Pendant Necklace

£11.46 SHAMTAM
Alchemy Blacksoul Bijou Pendant
CRONJAGER

Alchemy Blacksoul Bijou Pendant

£9.99 CRONJAGER
Turquoise Lava Stone Om Mala Meditation Necklace
SHAMTAM

Turquoise Lava Stone Om Mala Meditation Necklace

£18.00 SHAMTAM
−15%Gothic Lolita Necklace Black Lace Cut Out Heart And Flower Lolita Choker Collar
MILANOO

Gothic Lolita Necklace Black Lace Cut Out Heart And Flower Lolita Choker Collar

£6.41 £5.45 MILANOO
−25%The Colourful Aura Black Beaded Zircon Heart Shape 18Ct Gold Plated Asian Mangalsutra Necklace
DOROTHY PERKINS

The Colourful Aura Black Beaded Zircon Heart Shape 18Ct Gold Plated Asian Mangalsutra Necklace

£28.00 £21.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
Gold Black Heart Charm Necklace
CRONJAGER

Gold Black Heart Charm Necklace

£80.00 CRONJAGER
Worth the splurge4 pieces