Top Picks
Highwood Lace Low Suede Brogues
MAGGIE’S PICK LA REDOUTEHighwood Lace Low Suede Brogues
£104.00 LA REDOUTE
Britton Road Lace Up Leather Brogues
FIONA’S PICK LA REDOUTEBritton Road Lace Up Leather Brogues
£150.00 LA REDOUTE
Clarks Havisham Oak Black Leather Brogues,lace Up
GEMMA’S PICK DOROTHY PERKINSClarks Havisham Oak Black Leather Brogues,lace Up
£70.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
Torhill Moss Suede Shoes
AISHA’S PICK LA REDOUTETorhill Moss Suede Shoes
£139.00 LA REDOUTE
Clarks Batcombe Far Brogue Black Leather Brogues
HANNAH’S PICK DOROTHY PERKINSClarks Batcombe Far Brogue Black Leather Brogues
£95.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
How we pick

These picks came from Maggie, Fiona, Gemma, Aisha and Hannah, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

£50 to £1009 pieces
Clarks Havisham Oak Black Patent Brogues,lace Up
DOROTHY PERKINS

Clarks Havisham Oak Black Patent Brogues,lace Up

£70.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
Clarks Aldwin Limit Brogue Navy Leather Brogues,lace Up In Blue
DOROTHY PERKINS

Clarks Aldwin Limit Brogue Navy Leather Brogues,lace Up In Blue

£80.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
Sweaty Betty Tempo Train Adjustable Crew Neck Sweatshirt, Red, Women's
SWEATY BETTY

Sweaty Betty Tempo Train Adjustable Crew Neck Sweatshirt, Red, Women's

£90.00 SWEATY BETTY
Clarks Aldwin Limit Brogue Mid Tan Leather Brogues,lace Up In Brown
DOROTHY PERKINS

Clarks Aldwin Limit Brogue Mid Tan Leather Brogues,lace Up In Brown

£80.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
Clarks Havisham Oak Black Leather Brogues,lace Up
DOROTHY PERKINS

Clarks Havisham Oak Black Leather Brogues,lace Up

£70.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
Clarks Batcombe Far Brogue Black Leather Brogues
DOROTHY PERKINS

Clarks Batcombe Far Brogue Black Leather Brogues

£95.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
−26%Clarks Orinoco 2 Limit Black Leather Brogues
DOROTHY PERKINS

Clarks Orinoco 2 Limit Black Leather Brogues

£79.73 £59.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
−37%Clarks Craft Arlo Limit Brogue Tan Leather Brogues,oxford Shoes,lace Up In Brown
DOROTHY PERKINS

Clarks Craft Arlo Limit Brogue Tan Leather Brogues,oxford Shoes,lace Up In Brown

£95.24 £60.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
−20%Moshulu Atassi' Preppy Brogue In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Moshulu Atassi' Preppy Brogue In Black

£99.00 £79.20 DOROTHY PERKINS
Worth the splurge10 pieces
Flextride Plus Fast-in Leather Brogues
LA REDOUTE

Flextride Plus Fast-in Leather Brogues

£110.00 LA REDOUTE
Boxbee Walla Suede Ankle Boots
LA REDOUTE

Boxbee Walla Suede Ankle Boots

£139.00 LA REDOUTE
Boxbee Walla Leather Shoes
LA REDOUTE

Boxbee Walla Leather Shoes

£129.00 LA REDOUTE
Torhill Moss Suede Shoes
LA REDOUTE

Torhill Moss Suede Shoes

£139.00 LA REDOUTE
Melbury Lace Lace-Up Leather Shoes
LA REDOUTE

Melbury Lace Lace-Up Leather Shoes

£100.00 LA REDOUTE
Torhill Moss Patent Leather Shoes
LA REDOUTE

Torhill Moss Patent Leather Shoes

£139.00 LA REDOUTE
Highwood Moc Lace Low Suede Brogues
LA REDOUTE

Highwood Moc Lace Low Suede Brogues

£150.00 LA REDOUTE
Britton Road Lace Up Leather Brogues
LA REDOUTE

Britton Road Lace Up Leather Brogues

£150.00 LA REDOUTE
Men's Wide Fit Barker Sligo Oxford Shoes, Black / 9 / 4E
WIDE FIT SHOES

Men's Wide Fit Barker Sligo Oxford Shoes, Black / 9 / 4E

£329.99 WIDE FIT SHOES
Highwood Lace Low Suede Brogues
LA REDOUTE

Highwood Lace Low Suede Brogues

£104.00 LA REDOUTE

More like this

See all in Shoes →
Tan Buckle Flats That Have Caught Our EyeFlatsTan Buckle Flats That Have Caught Our EyeThe White Patent Heels on Our WishlistWhite HeelsThe White Patent Heels on Our WishlistFaux Leather Wedges Worth Putting Your Best Foot Forward InWedgesFaux Leather Wedges Worth Putting Your Best Foot Forward InOur Favourite Black Slip On Ballet FlatsBallet FlatsOur Favourite Black Slip On Ballet FlatsThe Gold Stilettos We Keep Going Back ToHeelsThe Gold Stilettos We Keep Going Back ToA Closer Look at the Best Party LoafersLoafersA Closer Look at the Best Party Loafers