Top Picks
Hunter Mire Mary Jane Sneakers at Free People in White, Size: US
ROSIE’S PICK FREE PEOPLEHunter Mire Mary Jane Sneakers at Free People in White, Size: US
£140.00 FREE PEOPLE
By Anthropologie Bow Point Mary Janes
ESME’S PICK ANTHROPOLOGIEBy Anthropologie Bow Point Mary Janes
£120.00 £60.00 ANTHROPOLOGIE
Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Storm 4-8
LEANNE’S PICK SOCK SHOPWomen's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Storm 4-8
£9.99 SOCK SHOP
Pavers Cushioned Touch Fasten Mary Janes In Grey
CHLOE’S PICK DOROTHY PERKINSPavers Cushioned Touch Fasten Mary Janes In Grey
£34.87 DOROTHY PERKINS
Elle 2 Pair Cosy Mary Jane Socks In Orange
FREYA’S PICK DOROTHY PERKINSElle 2 Pair Cosy Mary Jane Socks In Orange
£11.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
How we pick

These picks came from Rosie, Esme, Leanne, Chloe and Freya, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

Under £5017 pieces
Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Marmalade 4-8
SOCK SHOP

Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Marmalade 4-8

£9.99 SOCK SHOP
Pavers Cushioned Touch Fasten Mary Janes In Grey
DOROTHY PERKINS

Pavers Cushioned Touch Fasten Mary Janes In Grey

£34.87 DOROTHY PERKINS
Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Coral Blaze 4-8
SOCK SHOP

Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Coral Blaze 4-8

£9.99 SOCK SHOP
Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Rust 4-8 Ladies
SOCK SHOP

Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Rust 4-8 Ladies

£9.99 SOCK SHOP
Nola Jelly Mary Janes by FP Vegan Collection at Free People in Clear/Pink Combo, Size: US
FREE PEOPLE

Nola Jelly Mary Janes by FP Vegan Collection at Free People in Clear/Pink Combo, Size: US

£44.00 FREE PEOPLE
Nola Jelly Mary Janes by FP Vegan Collection at Free People in Coffee Bean, Size: US
FREE PEOPLE

Nola Jelly Mary Janes by FP Vegan Collection at Free People in Coffee Bean, Size: US

£44.00 FREE PEOPLE
Elle 2 Pair Cosy Mary Jane Socks In Coral
DOROTHY PERKINS

Elle 2 Pair Cosy Mary Jane Socks In Coral

£11.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
Elle 2 Pair Cosy Mary Jane Socks In Orange
DOROTHY PERKINS

Elle 2 Pair Cosy Mary Jane Socks In Orange

£11.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
Elle 2 Pair Cosy Mary Jane Socks In Burnt Orange
DOROTHY PERKINS

Elle 2 Pair Cosy Mary Jane Socks In Burnt Orange

£11.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Storm 4-8
SOCK SHOP

Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Storm 4-8

£9.99 SOCK SHOP
Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Forager 4-8
SOCK SHOP

Women's 2 Pair Elle Cosy Mary Jane Socks Forager 4-8

£9.99 SOCK SHOP
−29%Pavers Active Slip On Mary Janes In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Pavers Active Slip On Mary Janes In Black

£35.20 £24.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
−30%Pavers Active Slip On Mary Janes In Navy
DOROTHY PERKINS

Pavers Active Slip On Mary Janes In Navy

£49.99 £34.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
−31%Pavers Wide Fit Leather Touch-Fasten Mary Janes In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Pavers Wide Fit Leather Touch-Fasten Mary Janes In Black

£65.20 £44.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
−31%Pavers Wide Fit Leather Touch-Fasten Mary Janes In Navy
DOROTHY PERKINS

Pavers Wide Fit Leather Touch-Fasten Mary Janes In Navy

£65.20 £44.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
Elasticated slip-on shoes for women Pédiconfort
MADE IN PARADIS

Elasticated slip-on shoes for women Pédiconfort

£61.13 MADE IN PARADIS
−50%By Anthropologie Bow Point Mary Janes
ANTHROPOLOGIE

By Anthropologie Bow Point Mary Janes

£120.00 £60.00 ANTHROPOLOGIE
Worth the splurge8 pieces

More like this

See all in Shoes →