A good pair of black earrings has weight to it, even the small studs. You pick them up off the dish by your sink and there's a little drop in your fingers before you've put them anywhere near your ears, a sense that the metal or the resin has some substance rather than being stamped out of foil. The clasp should click shut with a bit of resistance, not the loose, rattly give that tells you it'll be in the bottom of a bag by Christmas.
Black earrings earn their keep differently depending on the time of year. In winter they sit well against dark coats and scarves without getting lost, which is the whole point, since gold or silver can disappear into a navy jumper but black holds its own line against black. Come summer, against bare shoulders and a tan, they read sharper, more deliberate, and that's when cheap ones show their age fastest, because sun cream and sweat get into any weak plating or glue and the colour starts to go patchy or grey rather than staying properly black. Keep them out of the shower, out of perfume spray, and wipe them over now and then with a soft cloth, and a decent pair will hold its colour for years rather than months. Store them somewhere they're not touching other metal pieces in a heap, because that's how black enamel chips and black plating scratches down to whatever's underneath, usually a dull gold that was never meant to be seen.
Where black earrings struggle is against anything already busy or already black in a different finish, patent against matte, for instance, which can look like two different decades arguing with each other. They also don't love competing with a statement necklace in the same colour, it ends up reading as one block rather than two considered choices. The difference between the ones worth having and the ones that end up at the back of a drawer is almost always in the finish: a true matte black that's been properly coated holds up, while a cheap glossy black laminate scratches to reveal plastic within a few wears. Good hardware has a proper post, a backing that doesn't wobble, and clasps that feel engineered rather than glued on as an afterthought. Resin ones should feel cool and solid, not light and hollow like a sweet wrapper.
Next time you're looking, pick them up before you check the price, and see whether the weight in your hand matches what your eye expects.
Black Vintage Earrings for Everyday Wear
Statement EarringsBlack Vintage Statement Earrings: What We’d Buy Now
Stud EarringsThe Best Looking Black Vintage Stud Earrings Out There
Stud EarringsA Closer Look at the Best Black Stud Earrings
Statement EarringsBlack Statement Stud Earrings That Elevate Everything
Sterling Silver EarringsBlack Sterling Silver Drop Earrings We Rate
Sterling Silver EarringsBlack Sterling Silver Earrings Worth a Closer Look
Sterling Silver EarringsPretty Black Sterling Silver Stud Earrings We Love
The Only Black Stainless Steel Earrings You Need to SeeAlso worth a lookStud EarringsI avoided stud earrings for years because they struck me as the earring equivalent of beige walls, the…See the collections →
Hoop EarringsBlack Stainless Steel Hoop Earrings Worth a Closer Look
Stud EarringsThe Black Stainless Steel Stud Earrings on Our Wishlist
Black Star Earrings for Everyday Wear
Statement EarringsBlack Star Statement Earrings That Finish Any Look
Stud EarringsBlack Star Stud Earrings We’d Buy Again
Statement EarringsBlack Statement Drop Earrings Picked by Us
Statement EarringsThe Black Statement Earrings Shortlist
Statement EarringsOur Pick of the Best Black Statement Hoop Earrings
Black Silver Plated Earrings Worth Adding to Your WardrobeAlso worth a lookHoop EarringsThere's a particular kind of morning, the one where you've got ten minutes, the outfit is already decided…See the collections →
Delicate to Bold: Our Favourite Black Pearl Earrings
Statement EarringsThe Best Black Pearl Statement Earrings to Shop Now
The Black Pendant Earrings on Our Wishlist
Black Personalised Earrings That Make a Lovely Gift
Black Minimalist Earrings We Love Right Now
Statement EarringsOur Favourite Black Minimalist Statement Earrings
Black Layered Earrings That Earn Their Place
Statement EarringsOur Favourite Black Layered Statement Earrings
Hoop EarringsOur Edit of the Best Black Hoop EarringsAlso worth a lookDrop EarringsDrop earrings used to mean one thing: a wedding guest reaching for the only pair of good jewellery…See the collections →
Statement EarringsBlack Hoop Statement Earrings We Can’t Stop Looking At
Black Heart Earrings That Elevate Everything
Black Flower Earrings Worth a Closer Look
Black Gemstone Earrings: Our Top Picks
Drop EarringsBlack Glass Drop Earrings That Elevate Everything
Black Glass Earrings Worth a Closer Look
Gold Plated EarringsBlack Gold Plated Earrings Worth Adding to Your Wardrobe
Black Emerald Earrings That Finish Any Look
