Pick one up and you can usually tell straight away from the weight of the fabric alone whether it's going to behave. A good A line skirt has a bit of body to it, enough that it holds its own shape off the hanger rather than flopping into a limp triangle. You want the waistband to feel sturdy under your fingers too, not that flimsy single layer of jersey that twists the moment you sit down.
This shape earns its spot across most of the year rather than being for one specific moment. A denim or cotton version takes you through spring and into a mild autumn, worn with bare legs and trainers or with tights once it turns. A heavier wool blend version is the one for winter, worn under a coat where the fullness doesn't matter because nobody sees it until you take the coat off indoors. For anything smarter, a satin or crepe version in a darker colour does the job without you having to think about it twice. In the ordinary wardrobe it sits well with a plain fitted top tucked in, because the shape only really works when there's a visible waist underneath, and it's forgiving over boots, trainers or heels depending on what you're doing with the rest of the day. A fitted jumper works for the same reason. What it doesn't love is anything else with volume on top, a loose blouse over it and the whole thing stops looking like an outfit and starts looking like two separate decisions.
If you've got none of these and you're starting from scratch, go for a mid weight cotton or cotton blend in a length that hits just below the knee, in a plain colour like navy or a soft grey rather than anything with a print. That length and that fabric cover nearly every situation you'll actually find yourself in, work, casual, slightly smarter, without you having to own three different skirts to manage it. Avoid anything too stiff to begin with, a skirt that stands away from your legs like a lampshade is a specific taste and not a starting point. Honestly, the cheap ones in a good fabric often outperform the expensive ones in a bad one, which tells you where to put your money.
Give it a year or two of actual wear and the fabric softens in a way that suits the shape, the fullness drops slightly and sits closer to the body, and the waistband loses that stiff new feel. A cotton one will have faded a touch at the front where your bag sits against it, which somehow makes it look more like yours and less like something off a rail.
Yellow A Line Skirts Worth a Closer Look
Wrap SkirtsThe Wrap A Line Skirts We Swear By
Work A Line Skirts on Our Radar
Wool A Line Skirts Picked by Us
White SkirtsOur Top White Satin A Line Skirts Right Now
White SkirtsShop Our Favourite White Maxi A Line Skirts
White SkirtsWhite Denim A Line Skirts That Work From Desk to Dinner
White SkirtsWhite A Line Skirts: What We’d Buy Now
Tiered SkirtsWhite A Line Tiered Skirts That Work From Desk to DinnerAlso worth a lookMidi SkirtsThe real tell on a midi skirt isn't how it looks in the mirror on day one, it's…See the collections →
The Only Wedding Guest A Line Skirts You Need to See
Velvet A Line Skirts: Our Top Picks
Our Pick of the Best Tulle A Line Skirts
Tiered SkirtsOur Edit of the Best Tiered A Line Skirts
Suede A Line Skirts We Rate
Striped A Line Skirts That Make Dressing Easy
The Slit A Line Skirts We Swear By
Silver A Line Skirts That Go With Everything
Satin SkirtsSatin A Line Skirts to Build Outfits AroundAlso worth a lookBlack SkirtsThe first black skirt I owned came from a supermarket clothing rail, a stretchy jersey thing with a…See the collections →
Maxi SkirtsSage Maxi A Line Skirts to Build Outfits Around
Ruffle A Line Skirts Worth a Closer Look
Ruched A Line Skirts Worth Adding to Your Wardrobe
Red SkirtsRed Mini A Line Skirts Worth a Closer Look
Red SkirtsRed Midi A Line Skirts We Rate
Purple A Line Skirts: The Ones Worth Your Money
Printed A Line Skirts Worth a Closer Look
Pink SkirtsThe Pink Satin A Line Skirts on Our Wishlist
Pink SkirtsOur Favourite Pink Maxi A Line SkirtsAlso worth a lookMini SkirtsA mini skirt only works if you've decided in advance what you're doing in it, because the length…See the collections →
Pink SkirtsThe Only Pink Lace A Line Skirts You Need to See
Jersey SkirtsPink Jersey A Line Skirts: What We’d Buy Now
Chiffon SkirtsPink Chiffon A Line Skirts Picked by Us
Pink SkirtsThe Pink Cotton A Line Skirts Worth Your Wardrobe Space
Pink SkirtsPink A Line Skirts: Our Honest Shortlist
